Nick Shaxson ■ Top UK politician compares banking divide to African oil separation
We’ve written plenty about the similarities between a ‘resource curse‘ afflicting mineral-rich countries in Africa and elsewhere and what we have termed a ‘finance curse‘ afflicting economies that are overly dependent on the financial sector. Britain is a case in point, with offshore activity a substantial part of the sector.
Now Vince Cable, the U.K.’s business secretary, has made another explicit comparison which resonates with our analysis. As the Wall St. Journal reports:
“Business Secretary Vince Cable said the British banking system outside the City of London finance district is “primitive” and similar to Africa, where he used to travel to visit oil and gas refineries owned by Royal Dutch Shell, his former employer.
Speaking to lawyers and bankers in a room overlooking the City of London, Mr. Cable said the contrast between the sophisticated technology of the finance district and the rest of the country’s banking system is extreme. He said it reminds him of the gulf between oil and gas installations in Africa and the rest of the continent.”
And he added:
“in Nigeria, “you could go to these world-class liquefied natural gas institutions, you know, the best technology in the world, and then there would be a barbed-wire fence around it and outside you would have Africa.”
Today’s blogger has spent much time in and around these oil-fueled African ‘pampered paradises’ – especially in Angola: read this New York Times article describing just how stark (and, to be honest, bizarre) the divide can be in the northern oil-rich Angolan enclave of Cabinda.
Leaving aside the unfortunate connotations of the word ‘primitive’, we would wholly agree with Cable. He has put his finger on one important aspect of the Finance Curse: a heavily protected and subsidised sector failing to link appropriately to the domestic economy and serving more as an ‘offshore island’ producing some jobs directly, but also wreaking a range of other harms elsewhere.