
Alex Cobham ■ Bad week for the big four

Last week was a bad week for the big four accountancy firms. These companies, which have for years marketed themselves as technocratic advisors to both governments and business, are seeing more exposure for the role they have played in driving the offshore economy, tax abuse, and the emptying of government treasuries around the world.
Firstly, the Paradise Papers revealed more about how the big four created a number of schemes to help companies avoid taxation. Amongst the papers were documents from PwC and Deloitte advising the private equity firm Blackstone on how they could not pay stamp duty on property sales and income tax from the rental on commercial property.
We also saw new research demonstrating how big four accountancy firms promote the use of tax havens by multinational companies. Research authored by Dr Chris Jones and Dr Yama Temouri of Aston Business School and our own chief executive, Alex Cobham demonstrates how big companies who have a big four accountancy firm as an auditor are much more likely to use tax haven subsidiaries.
You can see Alex talking about this new research in this video, and see our press release on the publication of the research here. The full paper is now free to download, through Aston’s kind provision of open access here.
Meanwhile in Italy, the big four auditors have been collectively fined €23m for colluding to fix government procurement tenders – hardly the behaviour of neutral, technical guarantors of financial probity.
And the Financial Times has published a variety of critical reaction to the role of the big four in the paradise papers, including ours:
Alex Cobham, chief executive of the Tax Justice Network, called for the establishment of an independent, global accounting regulator to scrutinise firms found to have promoted aggressive tax avoidance strategies.
“The Paradise Papers make clear that the Big Four play a critical role not only in the creation and aggressive promotion of tax avoidance schemes, but often also have a hand in the anonymous offshore ownership structures which can be put to all sorts of nefarious purposes,” he said.
The key question now is whether policymakers will be willing to impose the transparency and regulatory scrutiny that the big four so clearly need.
Related articles

The Making of Tax Haven Mauritius: the Tax Justice Network podcast, the Taxcast

Five key trends in 2023: Financial transparency, tax justice and inequality

Remunicipalización: el poder municipal: January 2023 Spanish language tax justice podcast, Justicia ImPositiva

Copa do Mundo das injustiças #43: the Tax Justice Network Portuguese podcast

Uncommon Wealth and the ‘boomerang effect’: the Tax Justice Network podcast, the Taxcast:

Doações milionárias à campanhas prejudicam democracia: the Tax Justice Network Portuguese podcast

Educación, derechización, inflación y justicia fiscal: October 2022 Spanish language tax justice podcast, Justicia ImPositiva

Tax and racial justice: the Tax Justice Network podcast, the Taxcast

September 2022 Spanish language tax justice podcast, Justicia ImPositiva: La constitución Chilena, Crimen Organizado, el nuevo contexto global de EE UU
