Nick Shaxson ■ The Offshore Wrapper: the week in tax justice, Olympic edition
Welcome to the Olympic Edition of the Tax Justice Network’s Offshore Wrapper.
Going for gold
There have been many reports in the world’s media focusing on how the $51bn spent by the Russian state has sparked virulent corruption.
On the eve of the games, the Head of Transparency International UK, Robert Barrington asked how much the UK financial sector has helped with the Olympian task of shifting money out of Russia.
He also criticized the International Olympic Committee for saying nothing about corruption in Sochi, which has stained the Olympic movement’s reputation.
But is this any surprise? The Olympics has a notorious tax avoidance history. Like many international sports organisations, it is based in Switzerland, which gives it a substantial tax break on its staggering income – an estimated $8bn between 2008-2012).
A report by Ethical Consumer estimated that the UK government lost £700m in taxes during the 2012 summer games from tax exemptions to the IOC and the London Olympic Organizing Committee. This was even before the corporation tax lost through tax breaks given to multinationals supplying the games.
Most worryingly of all, it seems that turning the Olympic village into a temporary tax haven for large and wealthy international businesses was a price demanded by the IOC for hosting the games. It’s a bit like the “tax bubble” stripping revenues out of poverty-stricken South Africa during the World Cup.
And let’s not forget that there’s only one Olympics, and only one World Cup: these are monopolies – and ultimately the super-normal economic profits that accrue, over and above the costs, are for private gain. Every reasonable economist knows what we ought to do with unearned rents from monopolies and their like: tax them, and at very high rates. Which is, of course, the very opposite of what’s happening.
Billions Flowing in and Out of the Philippines
This week we reported on a study from the Washington-based thinktank, Global Financial Integrity which has documented the vast quantities of illicit financial flows moving through the Philippines over the last 50 years.
The report found that $410bn flowed in and out of the country during the period, including US$132.9 billion in illicit financial outflows from crime, corruption and tax evasion. The report also found that a staggering 25% of the value of all goods imported into Philippines goes unreported to customs officials.
An article in thisismoney.co.uk provides a fascinating insight into the careers of former Olympians.
Former British Windsurfer Simon Goody, who competed in the 1988 games in Seoul, is now apparently a “tax mitigation expert” advising small time property speculators how to avoid taxes on rental properties in the North East of England.
He is quoted at a seminar in London promoting an offshore scheme and boasts:
‘I have cleared inheritance tax, I have cleared capital gains tax, I have cleared income tax, I’ve cleared national insurance. Any other kind of tax you can think of? I have cleared corporation tax.
‘This has got a 1,000-year shelf-life. The taxman cannot tax you retrospectively because you have given them full disclosure and signed it off. I have a lovely piece of paper from HMRC saying all your expenses have been cleared.’
The article, looking at how a modern day Gordon Gekko, Raj Shastri, wants to help us all become property millionaires, is well worth a read.
European Corruption Clampdown
This week the delayed Anti Money Laundering Directive returns to the European Parliament. The Directive will, among other things, insist that European Union nations set up a register of beneficial owners of companies.
This will mean that people controlling companies in Europe will find it harder to hide behind shell companies in secrecy jurisdictions to hide their identities, and should make it easier to combat money laundering, corruption and tax evasion. Crucially, the register should be publicly accessible to journalists, NGOs and other civil society organisations.
This week President Hollande continued his campaigning on this issue. During a visit to an online retailer in Paris the French President said that France would not tolerate the tax avoidance strategies used by global tech firms.
This came just days after the country slapped a billion-Euro tax bill on Google, ahead of a visit to the US where President Hollande will discuss the issue with President Obama.
The Offshore Wrapper was written by George Turner. To subscribe to our news output, please click here.
The week’s links
See also: Time for action on financial transparency euobserver
Bettel- Luxembourg won’t block expansion of EU savings directive Reuters
Lip-service, or a real commitment? Note the report states “in the long term”.
Swiss Finance Directors Push For Corporate Tax Reform Tax-News
“Despite the privileged taxation of international companies, they are nevertheless a key source of income for the state”
Avi-Yonah Posts Tax Papers on SSRN TaxProf
Reuven S. Avi-Yonah has posted several tax papers on SSRN:
Is it Time to Coordinate Corporate Tax Rates? A Note on Horst
The One Percent Solution: Corporate Tax Returns Should Be Public (And How to Get There)
No Country is an Island: Is a Radical Rethinking of International Taxation Needed?
Splitting the Unsplittable: Toward a Formulary Approach to Allocating Residuals Under Profit Split
Equatorial Guinea: Squandered riches Financial Times
Angola’s Biggest Threat Is Offshore – and It’s Not Piracy Think Africa Press
Illicit flows pick Africa’s pockets Business Report
Germany: Merkel party treasurer to resign over tax haven investments europe online magazine
See also: Germany’s SPD Seek Tougher Action On Tax Evasion Tax-News
Google’s tax returns are trop petite says Hollande The Register “French prez spits out Dutch sandwich”, Yahoo! move a blow to France The Irish Times, France will not tolerate tax avoidance, says François Hollande The Telegraph, andFrançois Hollande attacks US tech firms’ tax schemes The Guardian
U.S.: New IRS Commissioner Wants to Move Forward – We Should Let Him Tax Analysts Blog
Jamie Dimon’s Raise Proves U.S. Regulatory Strategy is a Joke Rolling Stone/Taiibblog
Citywealth International Financial Centre awards announced: winners include Jersey and Credit Suisse Financial Secrecy Media Monitor
Global version of FATCA could be a reality in a few years, say industry officials Thomson Reuters / Compliance Complete
See also: No more delays for FATCA, says IRS STEP
Greek-Swiss tax deal remains elusive Reuters
Is Switzerland retreating on Rubik?
A slightly updated English Summary of a working paper published in German last year on country-by-country reporting requirements for transnational corporations.Guernsey Royal Court decision places trustees at risk STEP
BVI companies claim GBP181 million from a Jersey trust administered in Guernsey, linked to property tycoon Robert Tchenguiz, who is connected with the failed Icelandic Kaupthing Bank.South Korea: UBS probed for tax evasion The Korea Times
Canada: Close Unfair Tax Loopholes in Federal Budget Canadians for Tax Fairness
Tax treaty uncertainty with India impacts Mauritius financial firms The Economic Times
Luxembourg Is Not A Tax Haven, Foreign Minister Asselborn Insists Tax-News
Note the familiar theme, and check Luxembourg’s record on the 2013 Financial Secrecy Index.
LLC information disclosure focus of bill Delaware Online
Delaware press reports on transparency of beneficial ownership issues
Europe must ‘walk the walk’ on corruption – Mo Ibrahim Thomson Reuters
Obama Tax Rhetoric on Offshore Profit Falls Shy of Action Bloomberg
See also: U.S.: Has the Tax Code Been Used to Reduce Inequality During the Obama Years? Not Really. Citizens for Tax Justice
The 1% Pay 37% of Income Taxes: So What? Real Clear Policy
Does campaigning for Fair Tax make a difference? Tax Research UK
Briefing paper on Emerging Capital Partners case and review of European law on money laundering Eurodad
Briefing by Eurodad member Re:Common and partner Counter Balance on the the Ibori case.
Zambia: Miners to get royalties reprieve The Herald
See also: British Company Vedanta-KCM Made $362 Million In 2013, Report Reveals CODESRIA , on the report Copper Colonialism: Vedanta KCM and the copper loot of Zambia
France to bill Google for $1.35 billion in taxes PressTV
“By transferring most of its revenue from France to Ireland, which enjoys a low corporate tax rate, Google has diminished the amount of tax it pays in France.” See also: Yahoo ups sticks to Ireland for European operations ITProPortal
UK: HMRC claims £100m victory in offshore tax evasion case International Adviser
Decaying London Mansions Prompt Punitive Tax Calls Tax-News
For more on London property, and absentee owners hiding behind offshore corporations based in tax havens, see Nick Shaxson’s Vanity Fair article A Tale of Two Londons
Raj says he can make you a property millionaire if you hand over £10,000. Do you believe him? This is Money
A reporter attends a seminar touting tax dodges via offshore
Ordinary people shortchanged by Covid recovery measures in Global South
To protect children’s right to education, governments must fight tax abuse
Tax and racial justice: the Tax Justice Network podcast, the Taxcast
Affaires Glencore et Sinosteel au Cameroun: Cas pratiques du besoin de plus de transparence sur les contrats extractifs en Afrique
Glencore and Sinosteel cases in Cameroon: Practical cases of the need for more transparency on extractive contracts in Africa
Switzerland – Submission to the UN Committee for the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women
20 September 2022